Help with Keepers????

[CDAG02]

10 team, H2H, 11x11

Need to choose 10 keepers from the following list. Right now I'm thinking Soto, Howard, Reyes, Cabrera, Kemp, Upton, Sabathia, Shields, Scherzer, Chamberlain. Should I keep Victorino or Hawpe over any of these?

Geovany Soto
Ryan Howard
Jose Reyes
Miguel Cabrera
Conor Jackson
Matt Kemp
Brad Hawpe
Jermaine Dye
Shane Victorino
Mark Reynolds
James Shields
Matt Cain
Francisco Cordero
Brian Wilson
CC Sabathia
Ted Lilly
Justin Upton
Chris Carpenter
Javier Vazquez
Max Scherzer
Joba Chamberlain

[Dodgerbluesc]

Victorino is nice but you seem to have enough speed.

Depending on the offensive categories and whether or not you feel that Hawpe could possibly be the one that pushes you over the edge in 2009 - I think Hawpe will be a better fantasy player than Scherzer in 2009. Scherzer is the better long term bet, but if you're going for it all this year go with Hawpe. I personally wouldn't because I feel you could easily re-aquire him in your draft/auction, but an argument can be made for doing so.

In terms of ADP - Victorino is going way way before Scherzer in drafts...

Good luck!

[rupertoooo]

I would go with the following:

Reyes
Cabrera
Howard
Kemp
Soto
Victorino
Upton

Sabathia
Shields
Joba