i woudl go with pujols. he is a monster and i have never had him on my team and it woudl be fun to have him. arod woudl be 2 but as i am a sox fan and cant stand yankees, but in fantasy you keep that stuff seperate. he shoudl do well but he doenst run as much anymore so even if he matches pujols hr rbi he wont touch his avg and without teh steals as an added bonus its a no brainer. then i would put wright ahead of reyes but i do think he will bouce back this year a bit but there are rumors that he will not leadoff but rather bat 3rd. if he dos that expect better runs and rbi numbers but the steals will suffer.
It's close but I like a healthy Pujols just because you can't touch him in four categories. ARod will beat him in steals and maybe HR but Pujols has the advantage in avg, RBI and runs about equal. That is why it is so close but I don't think you can turn down his average along with his consistent awesome stats across the board. He is the most reliable fantasy player out there.
these kind of questions shouldnt even be bothering us asking. Number 1 -3 overall you got too many people who vary with opinions and all of them are correct. You really cant go wrong with any of the picks ,really you are the best person to answer this. Do you want to fill a position with an absolute stud or you can go with the best player in the game at a very deep 1B postion. (Talking Pujols). It really depends on what type of draft you are seekign and what positions to fill, Arod, Wright,Pujols and Reyes, there is no wrong answer there.