Keep Hart or McLouth......?

[The Juice]

Who would you keep between Corey Hart and Nate McLouth, and what kind of numbers do you see each player putting up next year?

[j24jags]

This debate is actually ongoing here
viewtopic.php?f=7&t=369374

As you can see people are split pretty much right down the middle. I personally would go with Hart since I think McLouth's surrounding lineup is pretty lousy and I also think he's more flukey than Hart.

[HOOTIE]

Close, but Hart.

[kidsilk]

Very very close here as they are similar players. I like McLouth a tad bit more because I actually think he has more power by a hair. But, they should have similar stats:

Hart: 280, 22, 90,25
McLouth: 280, 25, 95, 22

please help

viewtopic.php?t=369589