Peavy for Hamilton?

[Chadgo5]

11 team auction, 6x6 (OBP+BAA), $260 cap for 19 starting players. Keep from 3 to 6.

I've got Peavy at $29 and have been offered Hamilton at $31.

My other keepers are (to date):
David Wright - $39
Nick Markakis - $13
Chris Davis - $1
Francisco Liriano - $10
David Price - $1

or I can keep Broxton at $3 and throw Peavy back in the pool and hope to win him or Cole Hamels (team dropped out) back in the auction.

[GOGOGADGETFLOW]

I would keep Peavy, Hamilton is a bit overrated at the moment.

[Montana168]

no way. hamilton's power numbers went down in the 2nd half and he probably won't have another monster year. he will still be good if he can stay healthy and in the league but he is definately risky. i like peavy more for your keepers as well.

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=369377