Would this trade work

[jaybogey]

Yahoo 12 team H2H I had 11th pick

C=Russell Martin (3)
1B=Carlos Delgado (9)
2B=Dustin Pedroia (1)
3B=Alex Gordon (11)
SS=Ryan Theriot(7)
OF=Hunter Pence (5)
OF=Corey Hart (6)
OF=Brad Hawpe (14)
UTIL=Joey Votto (16)

BN=Pablo Sandoval (12)
BN=Felipe Lopez (17)
BN=Jeremy Hermida (18)
BN=Jeff Francoeur (20)

SP=Johan Santana (2)
SP=Jon Lester (8)
RP=Jonathan Papelbon (4)
RP=Huston Street (13)
P=Diasuke Matsuzaka (10)
P=Gavin Floyd (15)
P=Joey Devine (19

BN=Mark Buehrle (21)


I am looking to trade either Corey Hart/Hunter Pence, Ryan Theriot, Huston Street and possibly Jeff Francoceur/Jeremy Hermida for His Carlos Quentin/Jose Reyes. Am I giving up to much?, he is weak in pitching Webb/Gallardo/Grienke/Scott Baker/Randy Johnson/Marmol/Joel Hanrahan and is loaded in the OF Quentin/Ordonez/Werth/Ludwick/Swisher/Span /Maybin

Should I throw in Dice K instead of street?

[Tenacious D-Store]

Nowhere near enough. It's not about quantity it's about quality. You can't just toss in a bunch of waiver trash and think it balances out the deal.

[eric31216]

it wouldnt work. you are forgetting that he would have to drop multiple players to even accept that trade. if you want reyes in any format, you are most likely going to overpay with QUALITY players.

[jaybogey]

He has lots of trash players as well like Ian Stewart and Mark Ellis

[j24jags]

Nowhere near enough. It's not about quantity it's about quality. You can't just toss in a bunch of waiver trash and think it balances out the deal.

Agreed not even close