trade McLouth for Ankiel/Hunter?

[oldmanbean]

I am trying to reduce payroll a bit, and have these two possibilities, same owner. I am planning on keeping 10 players. $200 payroll.
Straight points league.

trade McLouth ($13) for either Ankiel ($5) or Hunter ($10) AND swap draft positions (11th->5th, 25 rounds)

Would appreciate comments for each trade

Thank you

Glenn

C: Martin $9, Towles $10
1B: Pena $14, Butler $8
2B:Uggla $17, Theriot $13
3B: Gordon $12, Lowell $9
SS: Escobar $10, Drew $10
OF: McClouth $13, Fukodome $6, Markakis $13, Hamilton $13, Bruce $9
P : Danks $13, Lyon $13, J Shields $15, Duchsherer $13, Cueto $8, Sonnanstine $6, C Lee $13, Scherzer $9

[Tenacious D-Store]

I'd keep McLouth

[ayebatter]

I'd keep McLouth

Ditto.

[oldmanbean]

Thanks to you both ...

[smoovethug]

I'd stay put as well.

[CadensDad]

Yea another stay where you are vote

[oldmanbean]

Thanks again .... I have a bad habit of trading just to trade. This post hopefully can cure me!!

[Snakes Gould]

stay put.

[AussieDodger]

I'd wouldn't part with McLovin, that price is very reasonable.

I'd try to ship off Fukudome and Duschererer.

[oldmanbean]

I'd wouldn't part with McLovin, that price is very reasonable.

I'd try to ship off Fukudome and Duschererer.

I am dropping them, along with a few others. Our cutdown date is March 1, so next week I will have my keepers listed there. (When I start asking the annoying draft questions!!)