Ranking young pitchers

[RDD15]

Just out of curiosity.....

Which of the following pitchers would you want for the next 1, 3, and 5 years ranked 1-4?

Joba Chamberlain
David Price
Clayton Kershaw
Max Scherzer

[Tenacious D-Store]

Clayton Kershaw
Joba Chamberlain
David Price
Max Scherzer

[HOOTIE]

Just out of curiosity.....

Which of the following pitchers would you want for the next 1, 3, and 5 years ranked 1-4?

4 Joba Chamberlain
1 David Price
2 Clayton Kershaw
3 Max Scherzer

[Eagle Baseball]

WOW. OK I guess my guess is as good as the next guys.

1-Price: 2.6/Walk/9 5.8 Hit/9 Those are SICK stats. His K/9 was not great but it was in the minors so it should come up
2-Scherzer: 10.6 K/9 & 3.4 Walk/9 & 7.7 H/9
3-Joba: 10.6 K/9 & 3.5 Walk/9 & 7.8 H/9 Just took Scherzer over him due to my Yankee bias
4-Kershaw: 8.4 K/9 & 4.4 Walk/9 along with a 9.1 H/9 his line is the worst but he is the youngest

Again just a guess.

[CadensDad]

Kershaw
Joba
Price
Scherzer

[pepino]

1-Kershaw
2-Scherzer
3-Price
4-Joba

[eric31216]

long term i like

kershaw
price
joba
scherzer

[AussieDodger]

Just out of curiosity.....

Which of the following pitchers would you want for the next 1, 3, and 5 years ranked 1-4?

1-Joba Chamberlain
2-David Price
4-Clayton Kershaw
3-Max Scherzer

[rupertoooo]

What do all scouts salivate over, Lefty power pitchers who can pitch. We have two in this group and we could simply rank them starting there, but only one pitcher on this list has performed at a high level in the bigs for an extended time so we could start there, but only one name on the list seems to always pop up whenever scouts (the supposed experts) drool over potential and that name is:

1. Price
2. Joba
3. Kershaw
4. Scherzer

I tried to work a little philosophy into this ranking.