Who's a better keeper Mclouth or Hart?

[BigW27]

13 teams in a roto league, we get to keep (5) keepers.
Stat Categories are: R, HR, RBI, SB, K, AVG, OBP, W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP

Already selected:
Ludwick
Rios
Ortiz
Utley

Need to decide between Hart and Mclouth. I also have the option of keeping Soto, Aviles or Hardy.

Need help, have to hand in keepers by Friday.

Thanks for the help, post yours as well.

[ayebatter]

As long as Hart plays in Mil., and McLouth plays in Pit., its gotta be Hart.

[Tenacious D-Store]

As long as Hart plays in Mil., and McLouth plays in Pit., its gotta be Hart.

That has nothing to do with anything.

Hart had 15 more at bats than McLouth last season yet McLouth managed more hits, 6 more homeruns, 3 more RBI's, 37 more runs, a higher batting average, higher OPS, higher OBP, higher slugging percentage, walked 38 more times, and stole the same number of bases. It's clearly McLouth.

[CadensDad]

I'd go Mclouth as well

[HOOTIE]

I would drop Ludwick for Soto.

McClouth and Hart are close, but i prefer Hart. I think McClouth might regress a bit, while Hart increases.

[Dans]

Definitely McLouth. I don't see him regressing at all.

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd rather have Hart. I'd think McLouth's power last year is for real.

[BigW27]

I would drop Ludwick for Soto.

McClouth and Hart are close, but i prefer Hart. I think McClouth might regress a bit, while Hart increases.

I usually don't waste a Keeper spot on a Catcher, especially this year that there's allot of catchers out there that can put up the same numbers as Soto. Ludwick's power I believe is the truth. Thank you guys for all the help, It was a big help thanks again. I'll be submitting the following players:

Ludwick, Ortiz, Mclouth, Utley and Rios.

[BigW27]

I would drop Ludwick for Soto.

McClouth and Hart are close, but i prefer Hart. I think McClouth might regress a bit, while Hart increases.

I usually don't waste a Keeper spot on a Catcher, especially this year that there's allot of catchers out there (Martin, McCann, V.Mart and even Posada) that can put up the same numbers as Soto. Ludwick's power I believe is the truth. Thank you guys for all the help, It was a big help thanks again. I'll be submitting the following players:

Ludwick, Ortiz, Mclouth, Utley and Rios.

[rookies and cream]

I would drop Ludwick for Soto.

McClouth and Hart are close, but i prefer Hart. I think McClouth might regress a bit, while Hart increases.

I usually don't waste a Keeper spot on a Catcher, especially this year that there's allot of catchers out there that can put up the same numbers as Soto. Ludwick's power I believe is the truth. Thank you guys for all the help, It was a big help thanks again. I'll be submitting the following players:

Ludwick, Ortiz, Mclouth, Utley and Rios.

Why Ludwick over Hart? I also like Hart over McLouth.