Invictus wrote:Before I get into this, Id like to point out that it is just a suggestion, and just for fun - If its shot down, so be it.
One of my favorite aspects of FBC is posting my roster in the "Rate my Roster" section. Its just fun getting feedback and jabs from other fantasy players. I think it would be fun to have everyone's roster posted in that section and comment, similarly to this thread, on the rosters those your competing against.
HOWEVER, I also realize that many times people will respond with trade suggestions and point out weaknesses etc. Seeing as this is a competative league, I would understand how some might see this as getting extra help, and 'cheating' in some way.
Guess my question for the league is this - How do we feel about posting our rosters on these forums with the INTENT of having people comment on them. Good/bad/ugly? - This is only one league, and if people would prefer to not allow that kind of thing, thats fine by me, I just think it would be entertaining to get the cafe's perspective on our teams, especially in the inaugural season - perhaps post all the rosters in one post to prevent any claims of one team getting more 'help' than another, as well as prevent an extravagence of posts on the FBC forums?
I guess my view is this - I dont think its particularly cheating, as it's the manager who makes any decisions final, and beyond that, its his/her responsability alone for those decisions.
Invictus wrote:Before I get into this, Id like to point out that it is just a suggestion, and just for fun - If its shot down, so be it.
One of my favorite aspects of FBC is posting my roster in the "Rate my Roster" section. Its just fun getting feedback and jabs from other fantasy players. I think it would be fun to have everyone's roster posted in that section and comment, similarly to this thread, on the rosters those your competing against.
HOWEVER, I also realize that many times people will respond with trade suggestions and point out weaknesses etc. Seeing as this is a competative league, I would understand how some might see this as getting extra help, and 'cheating' in some way.
Guess my question for the league is this - How do we feel about posting our rosters on these forums with the INTENT of having people comment on them. Good/bad/ugly? - This is only one league, and if people would prefer to not allow that kind of thing, thats fine by me, I just think it would be entertaining to get the cafe's perspective on our teams, especially in the inaugural season - perhaps post all the rosters in one post to prevent any claims of one team getting more 'help' than another, as well as prevent an extravagence of posts on the FBC forums?
Just waiting for Chris to make his final pick! --- gotta be respectful :-p
I guess my view is this - I dont think its particularly cheating, as it's the manager who makes any decisions final, and beyond that, its his/her responsability alone for those decisions.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by j24jags » Mon Mar 30, 2009 11:26 am 
--- gotta be respectful :-p
