10 keepers due TODAY...who makes the team?

[AVladRod]

Hey guys, thanks for the help. Will help anyone with their post....its a standard 5 x 5 league, been 5 years building this team. 10 team league...PICK 10

I'm really down to keeping 3 between: E. Santana, Billingsley, Oswalt., Magglio, Bruce, and Hart

Some other top players possibly available in the draft: McLouth, Granderson, Pence, Harden, Lester, Wainwright.

ROSTER
C Doumit
1B Ortiz (not 1b eligible anymore)
2B Weeks
3B A-ROD
SS Rollins
OF Soriano
OF Beltran
OF C. Hart
UTIL M. Ordonez
UTIL J. Dye
Bench J. Bruce
Bench Hafner

SP Peavy
SP Halladay
SP Billingsley
SP E. Santana
SP R. Oswalt
RP Jenks, Broxton
Other Sp's: Bedard, Brett Myers, John Smoltz

Thanks alot for the help....

[WaCougMBS]

If I had to pick 3 of those 5, I would say you have two choices - keep:

1. E. Santana, Billingsly and Bruce if you think you'll have a quality shot at another hitter in the first/second, or
2. Billingsly, Bruce and Mags/Hart (depending on your hitting needs)

Tough to let Oswalt go, but I don't think you can keep 5 SPs in this format and I can't justify keeping him over Santana or Bruce in a keeper. Just curious, who are the 7 locks you have down on paper at this point?

[AVladRod]

my 7 locks are papi, arod, soriano, beltran, peavy, halladay, rollins

[WaCougMBS]

my 7 locks are papi, arod, soriano, beltran, peavy, halladay, rollins

K, that's what I thought - I think it really comes down to how many hitters to pitchers you want on your team, 6-4 or 7-3 (hitters-pitchers)

EDIT: Cause I can't count to 10

[murphysxm]

I'd go with Billingsley, Santana and Hart

help me if you can
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=368903

[Pogotheostrich]

1B Ortiz
3B A-ROD
SS Rollins
OF Soriano
OF Beltran
OF C. Hart
SP Peavy
SP Halladay
SP Billingsley
SP E. Santana

[nacho742]

I'd take Billingsly, E.Santana and Bruce.

[ayebatter]

1B Ortiz
3B A-ROD
SS Rollins
OF Soriano
OF Beltran
OF C. Hart
UTIL M. Ordonez
UTIL J. Dye
Bench J. Bruce
Bench Hafner

SP Peavy
SP Halladay
SP Billingsley
SP E. Santana
SP R. Oswalt
RP Jenks, Broxton
Other Sp's: Bedard, Brett Myers, John Smoltz

[C2ThaLo88]

keeping that many outfielders wouldn't allow him to play them all with papi who can only hit in the Util slot since he loses 1B eligibility (right?). If that is the case, then I'd either drop Bruce or Hart and keep E. Santana or Billingsly.

[HOOTIE]

Billingsley
Bruce
Hart