Should I veto?

[mekman21]

There's a trade I'm deciding if I should veto or not in my league...it is:

Lincecum, Chipper Jones, James Loney for David Wright and Matt Kemp

should I veto? I don't like it

[Kimbos Beard]

Why don't you like it?

[mekman21]

is it fair?

[MadDog36]

that trade needs to be allowed. There is no way that is vetoable.

Lincey a top starter packaged with a slightly lesser 3b but still quality player makes that part a wash. An upside 1b for an upside OF, wash out (kemp wins that, but its close enough). If you vetoed that I would quit.

[mekman21]

any one else? WHIR

[eric31216]

vetoing just b/c you dont like it is bad sportsmanship

viewtopic.php?t=368742 help plz

[Tenacious D-Store]

It doesn't even look unbalanced to me.

[Elsy]

It's a trade that has to be allowed. There doesn't seem to be any collusion or anything like that. Plus the fact that it is a fair trade.

[TheBull]

no way its vetoable...although whoever is getting Lincecum/Loney/Chipper is getting fleeced. Wright has more value than all 3 of them combined

[talan37]

Looks fine to me, and I am generally a stickler for fair trades. Loney is basically a throw in, and you have lince and chipper for wright and kemp. Chipper and kemp are pretty close, and wright and lince are very close(assuming you want pitching). Loney makes it a little more fair, if hes needed anyways.

Definitely a fair trade.