who would you keep? whir

[Fish Tacos]

I have three keeper spots. 12 team 5x5 roto league. I will have the fourth pick overall in the draft this year (24 rounds).

Very deep league. Two catchers, 1B, 2B, SS, 3B, CI, MI, three OF, Util, three SP, two RP, three P, four bench, one DL.

Of the following players which three would you keep if you had to draft them in the round next to there name?

Pedroia Round 7
BJ Ryan Round 15
Matsuzaka Round 8
Broxton Round 21
Quentin Round 24

WHIR

My choices are Pedroia, Ryan and Quentin

[MassYankee]

I agree with you.

Help me?
viewtopic.php?t=368825

[MadDog36]

Quentin Pedroia and Broxton (that's even better value for a closer, BJ Ryan's team is weak this year. Dodgers should be very competitive despite what they lost. I don't see any huge upgrades for any team in that division. Colorado lost a lot, The Dbacks kinda treaded water....

so i'd go for broxton.

[Fish Tacos]

looking at it a little closer, broxton may be a better choice. his adp is equal to ryan's and he is on a better team. i think ryan has better stuff though.

[smoovethug]

Quentin
Pedroia
Broxton

[eric31216]

pedroia broxton quentin

help please? viewtopic.php?t=368742

[Elsy]

Everyone is agreed on Pedroia and Quentin(great value for a power bat) so it comes down to Ryan and Broxton in my mind, and as a Toronto fan, I'd still go with Broxton especially in a keeper. He is the younger of the 2 and has more potential for improving his stuff even tho BJ has picked up a few mph on his fastball and has been working on his already sick slider in the off-season. Broxton is the better choice. You can always draft Ryan in the 2nd or 3rd round after your keeper section. Good luck

[HOOTIE]

Quentin
Pedroia
Broxton