Trade Pujols??? whir

[Elsy]

14 team 17 man keeper league on Yahoo. Just dealt Brad Lidge for Adrian Gonzalez and now wondering if I should try and move Albert for SP help.

Give - Albert
Get - Johan and Travis Snider

Is this too much to ask or not enough?

Keeper list:
C - Mauer
1B - Pujols/A Gonzalez
2b - Utley
3B - Rolen
SS - Aviles
OF - Ludwick/Scott/Wells/Dickerson/Nelson Cruz

SP - Halladay/Lee/Purcey
RP - Zeigler/Ryan/Downs/

[DaShiz23]

If you ask me, you are the one that should have all the leverage in any deal that includes Albert. I ask for WAY more than Snider. Improve heavily at 3B or OF in this deal. Otherwise, move on.

[GiantsFan14]

not enough imo. I'd need someone better with snider packaged with johan to trade pujols.

btw the lidge for agonz deal was an absolute steal for you.

[trevizzle]

yeah man you have a lot of leverage here...this is albert the great. and johan isn't even a clear cut number one this year...

i actually think your ok with halladay and lee... its third that seems weak to me, maybe even short. unless aviles plays like he did last season then your good. and wells sucks so maybe an upgrade in the of.

[smoovethug]

not enough imo. I'd need someone better with snider packaged with johan to trade pujols.

btw the lidge for agonz deal was an absolute steal for you.

Yes. And yes.

[Elsy]

Is this too much to ask for then: just offer thinking?

Gvie - Pujols/S Rolen/L Scott

Get - Johan/Aramis Ramirez/Snider

Only reason I put Scott in there is to even it up and would be dropping Scott off my keeper list anyway, if I did do this deal. Thanks for the the input so far, and the approval of getting AGON.

[GiantsFan14]

Is this too much to ask for then: just offer thinking?

Gvie - Pujols/S Rolen/L Scott

Get - Johan/Aramis Ramirez/Snider

Only reason I put Scott in there is to even it up and would be dropping Scott off my keeper list anyway, if I did do this deal. Thanks for the the input so far, and the approval of getting AGON.

i'd make this one. you have agonz to slip in at 1B, aram is an absolutely huge upgrade over rolen, and your rotation could really use johan. solid trade for you.

[Kimbos Beard]

Is this too much to ask for then: just offer thinking?

Gvie - Pujols/S Rolen/L Scott

Get - Johan/Aramis Ramirez/Snider

Only reason I put Scott in there is to even it up and would be dropping Scott off my keeper list anyway, if I did do this deal. Thanks for the the input so far, and the approval of getting AGON.

I think its a fair offer an could make sense for both teams. Johan will cement your staff and A-Ram is still a top player at a weak position. Offer it and see what happens.

[DaShiz23]

Is this too much to ask for then: just offer thinking?

Gvie - Pujols/S Rolen/L Scott

Get - Johan/Aramis Ramirez/Snider

Only reason I put Scott in there is to even it up and would be dropping Scott off my keeper list anyway, if I did do this deal. Thanks for the the input so far, and the approval of getting AGON.

I think its a fair offer an could make sense for both teams. Johan will cement your staff and A-Ram is still a top player at a weak position. Offer it and see what happens.

Much better!

[MadDog36]

Good idea.

does he have more than 1 3b.