Better Keeper: Soriano or Granderson?

[sigriffey]

If a league (H2H) with these stats: R, 1B, 2B, 3B, HR, RBI, SB, BB, AVG

Who do I keep for 2009-2010: Soriano or Granderson?

[Kimbos Beard]

I still want to say Soriano but I think it has to be Granderson based on those scoring Categories.


I view SB and AVG close to even
Soriano will probably give you more HR and RBI maybe more 1B
Granderson will give you more R, 3B, BB and 2B

Its close....I hate leagues with categories like this:)

[Tenacious D-Store]

Kimbo's dead on. I expected people to be saying Soriano and how it isn't even close. Sorino is getting up there (that sounds horrible, he's my age), while Granderson is at that magical age of 27 when rockstars die of heroin overdoses and baseball players break in to the best seasons of their careers. In a keeper it isn't very close, but the answer is Granderson.