Pence, Atkins, or Votto?

[doc watson]

5x5, 12 team league.

I can only keep one of the following:

Hunter Pence
Garrett Atkins
Joey Votto

Which one would you keep?

Thanks,

doc

[Tenacious D-Store]

Pence

[ayebatter]

Atkins

[eric31216]

i like atkins. you would have a higher chance of being able to redraft pence or votto in my opinion.

help? viewtopic.php?t=368742

[CadensDad]

Atkins

[TheBull]

I say Votto. Votto is on the brink of exploding, esp. in that ballpark in Cincy.

[GiantsFan14]

Votto is clearly superior to the others imo, i'd rank them:

Votto


Pence

Atkins

[HOOTIE]

Atkins isn't close to the other 2.

Votto barely over Pence

[TheBull]

i agree with that last statement. Votto/Pence. Take your pick. I love both of em. I just happen to like Votto a bit. 1B that will easily be 20/20. I see him around .290 27 105 25. I'll take that anyday.

[tribefan08]

Whoever is living in 2006 posting ATKINS needs to stop misleading this guy. Its between votto and pence and personally I'd go VOTTO a mile ahead of Pence. Votto can hit .300, possibly hit 30+ bombs and steal 10-15 (check his minor league SB's, he can run). With pence the average is a bit scary...... gotta have votto