Which 3 to keep? First year keeper league. WHIR

[Carnac]

Chris Davis 16th round
Stephen Drew 20th round
Brian Fuentes 20th round
Tim Lincecum 7th round
Jonathan Papelbon 5th round
Roy Halladay 9th round

These are my 5 top choices for keepers (can't keep anyone drafted in first 3 rounds last year).

Each player listed with round I would draft them in this year.

Davis is automatic. I am leaning toward Drew and Lincecum for my other 2.

What would you do?

[JRAMI]

this is easy,
C Davis
Lincecum (this should be automatic as well)
J Papelbon

please help
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=368711

[ayebatter]

Chris Davis 16th round
Tim Lincecum 7th round
Roy Halladay 9th round

[Tenacious D-Store]

Davis
Lincecum
Halladay

[eric31216]

davis and lincecum are easy. next would be halladay although fuentes would be good value also.

help? viewtopic.php?t=368742

[candyman]

this is easy,
C Davis
Lincecum (this should be automatic as well)
J Papelbon

please help
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=368711

I would switch out Papelbon and keep Halladay as a 9th rounder instead.

Davis and Lince are automatics.

Good luck!

Help me out?
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=368750

[Carnac]

I really had Lince pegged also. Was trying to decide between Stephen Drew (good value at 20th round), Halladay and Fuentes.

I may go with Halladay, as I was leaning toward him or Drew.

Anyone else?

[lastingsgriller]

if you're thinking about a closer.. Fuentes is way better than Papelbon.. for the value at least.. K-Rod set a record in that position last year and he was a bit shakey even.. i'd say worst case scenario Papelbon has 7 more saves than Fuentes.. barring injuries of course..


but overall I would say Davis, Lince, and Halladay and then don't draft a pitcher for a long time..