Which mock draft is better? WHIR!!!

[JRAMI]

Stat Category Value
R 1 1B 1 2B 2 3B 3 HR 4 RBI 1 SH 1 SB 3 CS -3 BB 2 IBB -1 E -1 CYC 10 IP 2 W 5 L -3 CG 5 SHO 10 SV 7 ER -1 BB -1 K 1 SVOP 1 RW -2 NH 20 PG 30 BSV -4


DRAFT A
2ND PICK OVERALL AND DRAFTED PLAYERS IN THIS EXACT ORDER
1. HANLEY RAMIREZ (SS)
2. CC SABATHIA (SP)
3. M RAMIREZ (OF)
4. R MARTIN (C)
5. C DAVIS (1B,3B)
6. C JONES (3B)
7. C FIGGINS (2B,3B)
8. J LACKEY (SP)
9. J BRUCE (OF)
10. M BRADLEY (OF)
11. J THOME (UT)
12. R DEMPSTER (SP)
13. B FUENTES (RP)
14. C KERSHAW (SP)
15. M TEJADA (SS)
16. J SMOLTZ (SP)
17. J DUCHSCHERER (SP)
18. R JOHNSON (SP)


DRAFT B
10TH PICK OVERALL AND DRAFTED PLAYERS IN THIS EXACT ORDER

1. CHASE UTLEY (2B)
2. TIM LINCECUM (SP)
3. A RAMIREZ (3B)
4. C QUENTIN (OF)
5. J PAPELBON (RP)
6. J VOTTO (1B)
7. JHONNY PERALTA (SS)
8. F LIRIANO (SP)
9. Y GALLARDO (SP)
10. C YOUNG (OF)
11. M WEITERS (C)
12. M BRADLEY (OF)
13. ADAM JONES (OF)
14. B MYERS (SP)
15. P BURRELL (OF)
16. C KERSHAW (SP)
17. J SALTAMACCIA (C)
18. J SMOLTZ (SP)

[FantasyStud]

Thanks for your help in mine!

I definitely like the first one. Great balance in my opinion of hitting and pitching.

[Gordo360]

I agree, the first one was a great draft (2nd one wasnt bad either).

[Carnac]

Both are good drafts. 1st one is better balanced.

good luck

thanks for help with mine

[reblaze369]

The 1st one is the most balanced, although I feel figgins was drafted too high.

www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/view ... p?t=368757

[abrage22]

Well in both I think you reached a little too far for some guys, in the 1st team for example i think you reached to early on davis, although i like him i just wouldn't draft him that early. and on team 2 I'm not likin the peralta pick. I personally like team 2 the best. The top 6 picks are IMO better than the top six on team 2, but i like the 2nd half picks on team 1 better.

[Chadwick0211]

I'd have to agree with the majority and say Draft A is more balanced. In my own opinion only, you may have reached a little bit with Martin for your 4th pick. As for draft B, that's not a bad looking draft either. Not bad at all. Peralta may have been a bit of a reach, but you can't go against a gut feeling.. Nice drafting!!

Help?
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=368722