Draft help. Wieters or Josh Johnson?

[DTChiefs]

20 team H2H keeper. Keep 8 + a rookie. Who should I take out of these two in the first round?

Stats- R, 1b, 2b, 3b, HR, RBI, SB, BB, K, Ave
W, L, CG, S, BB, K, Hld, ERA, WHIP, K/9

My team

C-
1b-M Cabrera
2b-H Kendrick
3b-
SS-
MI-
LF-J Bay
CF-N McLouth
RF-J Hamilton
Util-C Maybin

SP-R Nolasco
SP-J Cueto
SP-
SP-B Lidge
RP-
RP-
RP-
P-
P-
P-

[smoovethug]

Wieters for sure in a keeper.

[ayebatter]

Wieters

[Tenacious D-Store]

Both over hyped, but at least Wieters hype is based on more than speculation. Don't expect much this season. This is going to be like last years David Price scenario where the team gets our hopes up and keeps him in the minors 3/4 of the season. They'll ride out Zaun as long as they can but won't let Wieters just rot on the bench, he has to start in AAA.

[GiantsFan14]

it really depends who else is available if you should take on of those guys, but if i was just picking between the two i would take wieters (though i am not near as high on him as others are this year due to playing time concerns)