New Keeper Trade (WHIR)

[dave knight]

Give: Yovanni Gallardo
Get: Justin Upton

H2H 8x5 (singles, doubles, and triples for hitters).

We only keep 12 players per year.

Current roster:

C - C. Iannetta
1B - A Gonzalez
2B - D. Uggla
3B - E. Longoria
SS - J. Reyes
OF - N. Markakis, C. Quentin, V. Wells
Util - J. Votto, B. Abreu
BN - I. Stewart, T. Snider, M. Wieters, A. McCutchen, Adam Jones

SP - B. Webb, R. Oswalt, J. Danks, Y. Gallardo, C. Kershaw, M. Scherzer, S. Baker
RP - F. Francisco, M. Gonzalez

[djacks]

I would take it...you have more hitting cats so I would go with Upton

[tuckerman85]

I normally would have said no, but given that there are 8 hitting cats to 5 pitching, I would do it.

viewtopic.php?uid=33174&t=368484

[GiantsFan14]

meh, with Markakis, Quentin, Wells, Abreu and Adam Jones, McCutchen on your bench you really have no need for another OF. I'd stand pat with Gallardo.

[grandpa]

I would probably keep Gallardo as well- I think Upton has a few more years of being very inconsistient while Gallardo I think will be a stud as early as this year. You really can't go wrong with either though, but your lineup would suggest to stick with Gallardo.

Help with mine:
viewtopic.php?t=368500

[AquaMan2342]

Upton is arguably the most talented young player in baseball. No way I am passing on him here for Gallardo.