Trade: Huff for Hudson Rauch Sherrill Ducherser

[Brady2MossTD]

12 team roto league:

Send Aubrey Huff, Bal 3B from UTIL to O's
Receive Orlando Hudson, Ari 2B from O's to Bench
Receive George Sherrill, Bal RP from O's to Bench
Receive Jon Rauch, Ari RP from O's to Bench
Receive Justin Duchscherer, Oak RP from O's to Bench

Anyways, should I do this deal?

This is my team right now:
CATEGORIES:
Hitting: TB, R, SB, HR, RBI, BB, OBP, DPT
Pitching: H, ER, BB, WHIP, SVHLD, K, ERA, W, IP, K/BB

C: Russell Martin
1b: Miguel Cabrera
2b: Howie Kendrick
3b: Evan Longoria
ss: JJ Hardy
IF: Chris Davis
OF: Jay Bruce
OF: Ryan Ludwick
OF: Nelson cruz
OF: Sin Soo Choo
UTIL: Aubrey Huff
UTIL: Adam Lind
BE: Colby Rasmus
BE: Matt Gamel
BE: Cameron Maybin
BE: Travis Snider
BE: Matt LaPorta.

P: Tim Lincecum
P: Clayton Kershaw
P: Max Scherzer
P: Gil Ga Meche
P: AJ Burnett
P: Joey Devine
P: Brad Zieglr
P: Matt Lindstrom
P: Brandon Lyon
BE: Chris Volstad
BE: Justin Masterson
BE: Gavin Floyd
BE: David Purcey
BE: Kyle Davies
BE: Clay Buchholz

I'd probably drop....Buchholz....Davies....who else? (to make room, if I accept this deal)

Thanks!

[CadensDad]

It's a good deal for you huff wont have the same kinda of year, But i'd look to have him combine Hudson and sherill maybe for someone else 4 for 1 is too hard b/c you have to drop sooo many

[Brady2MossTD]

It's a good deal for you huff wont have the same kinda of year, But i'd look to have him combine Hudson and sherill maybe for someone else 4 for 1 is too hard b/c you have to drop sooo many

Thank you, anybody else have input?

[Brady2MossTD]

Please?

[tuckerman85]

I agree with Caden, you don't want to have to drop 3 additional players... If you can get that kind of return for Huff, without dropping the players I'd go for it.

viewtopic.php?uid=33174&t=368484

[GiantsFan14]

no way i'd make this trade. the only time i'd even think about trading quality for quantity is in very deep leagues where it's hard to get starters at every position. this guy is basically just taking the worst 4 players on his team and trying to turn it into a solid player. combine that with having to drop 3 players just to make the trade and its a definite no go.