Braun trade offer

[sreill]

So the way I see it Peavy and Fielder for Braun. I do not like this deal unless you get his 1st round pick in return.

This is the proper analysis. What type of players will be available with your next pick if you make this trade? I think thats how you have to look at. It's Fielder and Peavy for Braun and (insert your next pick here). Look at the trade that way and then make the move.

players available now would be:

Fielder
Carlos lee
Peavy
Haren
ichiro
markakis
mc louth
rios
dunn
granderson
burnett
so i get with 10th pick one of these guys. maybe dunn or markakis fall to me

[sreill]

I think you do the deal, but you need to work your butt off to try to get some value out of Peavy. If you don't get some sort of a draft pick out of him, you are just cutting value.

This is a doable trade, but it makes a second trade necessary.

i would have to drop peavy so he wouldnt be mine to trade

[RDD15]

I think you do the deal, but you need to work your butt off to try to get some value out of Peavy. If you don't get some sort of a draft pick out of him, you are just cutting value.

This is a doable trade, but it makes a second trade necessary.

i would have to drop peavy so he wouldnt be mine to trade

I am under the impression that you are still before your keeper deadline, right?

Or would you have to cut Peavy immediately, and if so, how is your potential trading partner still able to choose between Braun and Soto as a keeper?

[sreill]

we put our keepers in, but if we trade a keeper, we can go back to our team and grab our next best guy so that we all go in with 4 keepers

[RDD15]

we put our keepers in, but if we trade a keeper, we can go back to our team and grab our next best guy so that we all go in with 4 keepers

Then try to stall the Braun deal until you have sold Peavy off.

[Eagle Baseball]

I like Braun but I think Peavy + Fielder > Braun.

If you don't do the trade your team will look like this after your #10 pick:
Santana-K
Longoria-K
Berkman-K
Peavy-K
Fielder-#1 pick
#10 pick

If you do the trade your team will look like this after your #10 pick
Santana-K
Longoria-K
Berkman-K
Braun-K
#10 pick

I just think having that one extra player is worth more than Braun.

[sreill]

I like Braun but I think Peavy + Fielder > Braun.

If you don't do the trade your team will look like this after your #10 pick:
Santana-K
Longoria-K
Berkman-K
Peavy-K
Fielder-#1 pick
#10 pick

If you do the trade your team will look like this after your #10 pick
Santana-K
Longoria-K
Berkman-K
Braun-K
#10 pick

I just think having that one extra player is worth more than Braun.

This is what I am thinking

[RyeWhiskey]

I like Braun but I think Peavy + Fielder > Braun.

If you don't do the trade your team will look like this after your #10 pick:
Santana-K
Longoria-K
Berkman-K
Peavy-K
Fielder-#1 pick
#10 pick

If you do the trade your team will look like this after your #10 pick
Santana-K
Longoria-K
Berkman-K
Braun-K
#10 pick

I just think having that one extra player is worth more than Braun.

This is what I am thinking

Absolutely. Braun is a beast but I'll take Fielder and Peavy over him in a keeper, easy.
Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=368407

[sreill]

Thats what Im thinking. I love Braun but I dont wat to chase the name. Is fielder and berkman better than braun for my team?

[BoBtheMule]

don't do the deal... stall it, deal peavy for a first... maybe a 2nd. Then do the deal... that'd be the only way I'd do the deal.