Which Pitching Prospect?

[Niffoc4]

Which SP would you prefer? This is how I would rank them, but I'm not sure about Cahill over Anderson.
Trevor Cahill (Who I have right now)
Brett Anderson
Chris Tillman
Brian Matsusz

Jordan Zimmerman

[thomasps3]

Thta is lcose, I would just flip flop the top 2. Isn't it interesting how Anderson was just a minor part of the As/DBacks trade, but now has really rocketed up the prospect list? I thought Carlos Gonzalez would be the one who would be the star....funny

[J35J]

Trevor Cahill
Brett Anderson
Brian Matsusz
Chris Tillman













Jordan Zimmerman

[J35J]

I thought Carlos Gonzalez would be the one who would be the star....funny

Nobody is a star yet...

[kab21]

JJ got the order right although you could flip Anderson and Cahill. But I think in fantasy Zimmerman is closer to Tillman and Matusz than they are to Anderson and Cahill.

[Niffoc4]

Thanks for your help guys... Can someone tell me why Anderson over Cahill (or visa versa?)

[TurdFerguson]

Really not buying the Brett Anderson hype..

I think Tillman has the highest ceiling of the bunch

[Yoda]

They are pretty close Anderson and Cahill. Anderson has better stuff though.

I like Zimmerman. I think he has a chance to surprise people.