Pick 2 Keepers. I like Braun & ?

[Cyclone177]

Ok, I am for sure keeping Braun, but I can't decide between Lance Berkman or Hamilton. Lance had a huge year last year, but tapered big time in the second half. Also, he seems to have a good year, and then a mediocre year. Hamilton was huge for me but also tapered in the second half, but his injuries sort of scare me. Plus Milton Bradley is gone and he was a big part of that lineup.

Are there any pitchers you would keep over Berkman\Hamilton?

C Pudge
1B Berkman
2B Brian Roberts
3B Ryan Braun
SS Michael Young
OF Soriano
OF Carlos Lee
OF Josh Hamilton
UTIL Corey Hart

Scott Kazmir
Felix
Smoltz
Javier Vazquez
Andy Pettite
Oliver Perez
Cueto
Volquez
Joba

[Tenacious D-Store]

The logical choice would probably be Berkman. I know people are still skeptical of Hamilton but his performance at the home run derby proved to me that he is the real deal as a serious power threat. The talk that continues to surround him about what if he falls back in to his drug addictions is nonsense. Take a serious look at him, and his obvious dedication to being an all star caliber player and tell me you think that is a serious possibility. I'm keeping Braun and Hammy.

[Cyclone177]

Thanks for the quick reply. I was actually leaning to Hamilton and Braun, I have had them the last 2 years, so I really like them both. The drug issue doesn't worry me at all, it is the health\consistency that really scares me. I am really having a tough time deciding between Hammilton and Berkman. Big Puma was the man 1st half last year. But so was Hamilton. Damn!!!!

[HOOTIE]

Braun and Hamilton. Not even close.

[Pogotheostrich]

Hamilton.