Keep Kershaw or Felix in Roto? CDavis or JBay in H2H?

[carpediem]

In a H2H standard 5x5, which 2 would you keep from:
CDavis
Alexei
Bay
Chipper
(I am already keeping Pujols, Reyes, Braun, Beltran, Hamilton, Webb)

In a Roto 6x6 (including OPS and HOLDS), which 2 would you keep from:
CDavis
Kershaw
Felix
Cain
(I am already keeping Braun, Rollins, Holliday, Hamilton, Teixiera, Crawford)

[mission27]

Davis in both.

Alexei and Felix.

[HOOTIE]

Bay
Alexei

Davis
Felix

[MotorCityKitties]

Davis Bay
Davis Felix

[Tenacious D-Store]

Bay for sure after he lit it up with the Sox, amazing what a real team does to his value. I like Chipper too, but since OPS is not a cat in this league, I'd go with a younger healthier Davis. Alexei will only be eligible at SS next season, and you have Reyes. Doesn't make sense to keep him.


I'll take Davis in the second league as well, and I'm going to say Cain since Felix has had a history of injury even in the minors.

[sappisgod]

Davis in both, Bay in the first, and Felix would be the safer bet in the second. I'd be tempted a lot by Kershaw, but there's probably a better chance you can get him back in the draft than Felix.