keep league ranking

[Yoda]

12 team, OBP in place of AVG league. My keepers:
Pujols
Braun
Rollins
Beltran
Davis

I have the 9th pick at the draft and available players:
Brandon Phillips
Nick Markakis
Jake Peavy
Russell Martin
Brian McCann
David Ortiz
Joe Mauer
Chipper Jones
Jonathan Papelbon
Adam Dunn
Magglio Ordonez
Shane Victorino
Nate McLouth
Francisco Rodriguez
Bobby Abreu
Dan Uggla
Joe Nathan
Derrek Lee
Garrett Atkins
Rafael Furcal
Scott Kazmir
Carlos Pena
Victor Martinez
Michael Young
Roy Oswalt
Brad Lidge
Aubrey Huff
Hunter Pence
Robinson Cano
Troy Tulowitzki
James Shields
John Lackey
Stephen Drew
Jermaine Dye
Mariano Rivera
Chone Figgins
Chad Billingsley
Felix Hernandez
Joakim Soria
Daisuke Matsuzaka
Ervin Santana

How would you rank these guys and which players should I target?

[The Artful Dodger]

Brandon Phillips
Nick Markakis
Jake Peavy
Adam Dunn
David Ortiz

Brian McCann
Joe Mauer

Nate McLouth
Dan Uggla
Shane Victorino

Russell Martin

Just focusing on the 9th pick, these would be my top options in tiers. With average out of the question, I'd rank Dunn a bit higher naturally. If you're in a 2 C league, I'd rank McCann and Mauer up there. I have McLouth/Uggla/Victorino closely ranked while again, Martin is one of the last choices I'd consider if you're playing with two catchers.

[ayebatter]

I'll give you bats and arms separate.

Markakis
Ortiz
Dunn
McLouth
Phillips
Pena
Pence
Atkins
Dye
McCann

Peavy
Pap
Lackey
Soria
FRod
Nathan
Bills

hope this helps