This is a standard Yahoo! 5x5, 12 team, H2H league...
I Just did the following trade... I GET: Aviles, Lincecum, Hoffman, and Sherrill I GIVE: Alexei Ramirez, Tori Hunter, Joe Nathan, and Chris Ray
Now here is my team.
C - Pablo Sandoval 1b - Justin Morneau 2b - Brian Roberts 3b - Evan Longoria ss - Jimmy Rollins of - Ryan Ludwick of - Adam Dunn of - Nelson Cruz ut - Joey Votto bn - Mike Aviles bn - Justin Upton bn - Milton Bradly
sp - Tim Lincecum sp - Jon Lester rp - Trevor Hoffman rp - George Sherrill p - Adam Wainwright p - Eric Bedard p - Joe Saunders bn - Justin Duchscherer bn - Johnny Cueto
What do you like, what don't you like? I know I need some relief help. Who should I make expendable and who should I go after? or Should I just sit back?
I really like Sandoval and Upton. Solid across, I would worry about Bradley and Ludwick but since you have Upton you really don't need to go shopping. Nice job picking up Lincecum, your team really needed a SP. Keep an eye on the revolving door at RP.
Like someone said in my thread, Sandoval is a risk. He doesn't have the power of last years cheap catcher turned star, Soto. But if he gets playing time he has the pedigree, plus he could play a lot at first and third which is less strenuous while keeping that nice catcher eligibility. He doesn't seem like a home run guy but then again he's really young.
You know what you're getting with Morneau - top 10 production in 4 categories. The batting average is even better than on most comparable 1Bs. Roberts isn't elite, but has solid AVG, runs, and great SB - just outside the top 5. Longoria is fantastic 5 cat player; 3rd best at 3rd. Rollins may be overrated, but is in top 3-4 with decent stats and loves to run. Ludwick and Dunn are upper-middle tier and will give you RBIs, power, and OBP. Cruz is a risky choice as a starter, though, hard to tell what you'll get with him. Could be this years Ludwick though. Votto has enough upside to break the Top 10 1st basemen, and the other bench players have upside which is good.
Pitching is a mixed bag outside of obviously gifted Lincecum. Lester is a very good option. Wainwright is a risk because his innings have been cut back in recent years. Bedard is very overrated, he is a mid-tier pitcher. Saunders may not be good enough for a 12 team mixed, in my view. Duchscherer and Cueto are intriguing, if Duch can recover and Cueto matures. Still the two are lower-middle tier.
You do need more closers. I have a weird fetish of never going out of the way to get saves, but if you can market one of your starting pitchers for a nice stable closer then do it. Maybe Bradley has some value in that endeavor as well (though I like him slightly over Cruz).
Personally I wouldn't have made that trade. It was a lot to give up for a pitcher who had such a heavy workload for the first time in his career last season. Plus now your closer situation is a little scary. I wouldn't be surprised if Ray ends up closing again this season before too long which would leave you with a 42 year old as your only closer. I guess you needed another pitcher, but you could have got a solid one a lot cheaper. Oh well, what's done is done and you can always find saves later.
Other than that...I don't like Sandoval as the only catcher on your roster. He could be real good, but it would have been nice if you drafted another one. I think your team has nice balance and if you can pick up another closer there's a good chance you'll be near the top. If anyone gets hurt early (ie. Ducscherer) you can always dump them for a good reliever who has a chance to close. Unless there are any actual closers available.
Generally I don't like big trades or big name trades before the season starts, but I think this one worked for you. It's impressive that you still have such a good infield even after moving Alexi.
The previous poster is right you have opened up a big hole in your relief pitching, but I think that is better than going into the season with Jon Lester/Adam Wainwright as your "aces". I think its easier to find a closer than it is to find an ace.
I agree, Wainwright and Lester are decent guys. Best thing about RPs is that if you watch closely some of the teams this season, you're sure to find pitchers that will close for you and give ya some SVs.
It's a good, balanced team. Sometimes you might find a C during the season as well, kind of like Geovany Soto.