Do I make this trade?

[dpdale]

Ok, I have more keeper players than I have spots for and I want to make a 2 for 1 trade.

Here's what I'm thinking -

Teixeira or Braun and J.Santana for Roy Halladay

Should I do it or just make a tough keeper decision?

[Eagle Baseball]

Ok, I have more keeper players than I have spots for and I want to make a 2 for 1 trade.

Here's what I'm thinking -

Teixeira or Braun and J.Santana for Roy Halladay

Should I do it or just make a tough keeper decision?

are you sure that is what you meant to type?

[mission27]

Why would you do that? Your giving up the best player in the deal no matter what (Tex or Braun), and Johan isn't that far behind Halladay.

[Johnny Tuttle]

You would be giving up the two best players in the deal. That's a big no.

[GiantsFan14]

that's silly... teixeira, braun and santana are all significantly more valuable than halladay.