Team Kinsler or Team Reyes

[Wile E Coyote]

I am joining a 12 team HTH keeper league that has 2-3 openings
Categories: R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OPS, W, L, SV, K, ERA, WHIP

I have been offered possibly one of the following 2 teams to pickup
There are 5 keepers

Which 5 would you keep from each team? And given the choice, which team would you pick? I'm leaning towards Team Kinsler.....THANKS!

Team 1 notables:
Ian Kinsler
Lance Berkman
Carlos Beltran
Roy Halladay
Ken Youkills
Chipper Jones

Team 2 notables:
Jose Reyes
Ryan Braun
Justin Morneau
Russell Martin
Nate McLouth
Shane Victorino
Alexei Ramirez

notable free agents (although preference may go to 1-2 new joining teams): Prince Fielder, Dustin Pedroia, Garrett Atkins, Jimmy Rollins, Carlos Quentin, Nick Markakis, Alfonso Soriano, AJ Burnett

[MadDog36]

Team 1 notables:
Ian Kinsler 2b
Lance Berkman 1b
Carlos Beltran of
Roy Halladay sp
Ken Youkills 3b
Chipper Jones 3b

Team 2 notables:
Jose Reyes ss
Ryan Braun of
Alexei Ramirez 2b
Justin Morneau 1b
Russell Martin c
Nate McLouth of

what kind of pitching does team 2 have, what 3b will be available in the draft??
I think I'd take team 2 because your filling 3 of the toughest positions with quality options (reyes martin and alexei).

A-Ram really is not far off of Kinsler IMO. I think he'll run more this year. The kid has already proven he has good power. So I believe I'd go with team 2 and kick Vic to the curb.

[WyldStallyn]

team kinsler looks better for competing in the short term, but long term outlook looks better with the second team. i would probably go with team reyes, braun, morneau, alexei, mclouth (or whoever you prefer of those remaining, theyre pretty even)

[NittanyLions1]

Team 1 notables:
Ian Kinsler 2b
Lance Berkman 1b
Carlos Beltran of
Roy Halladay sp
Ken Youkills 3b
Chipper Jones 3b

Team 2 notables:
Jose Reyes ss
Ryan Braun of
Alexei Ramirez 2b
Justin Morneau 1b
Russell Martin c
Nate McLouth of

what kind of pitching does team 2 have, what 3b will be available in the draft??
I think I'd take team 2 because your filling 3 of the toughest positions with quality options (reyes martin and alexei).

A-Ram really is not far off of Kinsler IMO. I think he'll run more this year. The kid has already proven he has good power. So I believe I'd go with team 2 and kick Vic to the curb.

Id agree with this assessment and would go with team 2, even though I love Kinsler. Team 1 drop Chipper, Team 2 drop Morneau and try and get Fielder in the redraft! The other option is to keep Morneau and try and get Quentin, Markakis, or Soriano in the redraft

[HOOTIE]

Team B

Reyes
Braun
Alexei
Morneau
Martin

McLouth close

[ayebatter]

Team 2 notables:
Jose Reyes
Ryan Braun
Justin Morneau
Russell Martin
Nate McLouth
Shane Victorino
Alexei Ramirez


I'm not keeping a catcher or the flyin' Hawaiian.

[mission27]

I'll take team A. Keep everyone except Chipper.

[Dan Charette]

Team 1 notables:
Ian Kinsler 2b
Lance Berkman 1b
Carlos Beltran of
Roy Halladay sp
Ken Youkills 3b
Chipper Jones 3b

Team 2 notables:
Jose Reyes ss
Ryan Braun of
Alexei Ramirez 2b
Justin Morneau 1b
Russell Martin c
Nate McLouth of

what kind of pitching does team 2 have, what 3b will be available in the draft??
I think I'd take team 2 because your filling 3 of the toughest positions with quality options (reyes martin and alexei).

A-Ram really is not far off of Kinsler IMO. I think he'll run more this year. The kid has already proven he has good power. So I believe I'd go with team 2 and kick Vic to the curb.

I would keep team 2 .

[oakscorps]

I would keep team 2 and its not even close, theres way too much age in team 1 and injury concerns

For team 2 I would keep

Reyes
Martin
Ramirez
Braun
Morneau

THe only reason I would keep Martin over Mclouth is because of depth and I think Mclouths numbers will drop some since he has no one around him

[MotorCityKitties]

Yeah it's team 2 for me.