Team A or B

[cubbieball10]

5 x 5 scoring, 10 team league, keep 10.

Which team do you like more:

Team A:
Justin Morneau
Ian Kinsler
Hanley Ramirez
Garrett Atkins
Jason Bay
Ichiro Suzuki
Jermaine Dye
Josh Beckett
Joakim Soria
Jake Peavy

Team B:
Justin Morneau
Ian Kinsler
Hanley Ramirez
Aramis Ramirez
Jason Bay
Ichiro Suzuki
Jermaine Dye
Josh Beckett
Joakim Soria
James Shields

Is there any one out there who would take Team A over Team B. If so, why?

[terribletetrick]

I take A, I like Peavy enough over Shields to make up for the difference in Aramis and Garrett. Peavy is pretty damn good and he usually bounces back after a semi down year. Remember 2007 when he won the NL pitching triple crown.

[MadDog36]

You could perhaps use a 3b upgrade, but not at the expense of peavy. keep this group. try to pluck an upside catcher, 3b, SP and OF in the draft (for depth).

Justin Morneau 1b
Ian Kinsler 2b
Hanley Ramirez ss
Garrett Atkins 3b
Jason Bay of
Ichiro Suzuki of
Jermaine Dye of
Josh Beckett sp
Jake Peavy sp
Joakim Soria rp

[WyldStallyn]

i think there's a bigger difference between peavy and shields than between aram and atkins, so i like A

[kidsilk]

Team A

please help

viewtopic.php?t=367213

[jmlevy]

i think there's a bigger difference between peavy and shields than between aram and atkins, so i like A

I like this answer

Please help: viewtopic.php?t=367531