Manny Ramirez or Carlos Lee for 09?! WHIR!!!

[CadensDad]

For 09 Many, for 10 small edge to Lee for 11 Lee for sure,

So if your playing with restrictions on how long you can keep players I'd go Manny. But if it's unlimited I'd go Lee

[GiantsFan14]

Carlos Lee, but it's really really close.

[WyldStallyn]

i prefer lee. people seem to be ignoring 2006 and 2007 when manny missed 30 games each season, and in '07 he really didn't hit that great. lee just seems to be a much safer choice

[kidsilk]

Manny for me too. It is close for sure but I just think he has a little more upside. Lee is great but Manny is better.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=367213

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd take C Lee. Chances are Manny signs but it is close enough where I won't take a chance on Manny sitting out or being out of shape to start the season.

[jcde7ago]

Thanks for the replies guys...I think I almost have to lean towards Carlos Lee because it is a Keeper format after all...although the tally in this thread was 7 for Manny, and 6 for Carlos Lee, so it was extremely close. Our league has 10 choices that are wittled down to 6 keepers after Spring Training so that we are able to watch their Spring Training performances and avoid any potential injuries/problems so I might have to wait on this decision until the very last day...but thanks for the input

[Kimbos Beard]

I am going to tie it up again then, because I am going to go with Lee by an ever so slight margain.

Lee is Mr. Consistency year in and year out. As a previous poster also mentioned, he was absolutely tearing it up last year when he got hurt and was on pace to put up ridiculous numbers.

It's razor thin by I go Lee in a keeper league.