1. Hanley Ramirez
2-4. Albert Pujols, David Wright, Alex Rodriguez
5-9. Jose Reyes, Ryan Braun, Miguel Cabrera, Grady Sizemore
I agree with skmo2345 with the top 9 so if any of them fall to you grab them.
At the turn I would look for two IF's. Hamilton is a solid choice here or you could reach with Upton and Holliday is a option but I would stay still go infield here.
1B-Teixeria & Howard
2B-Utley & Kinsler
Not that I think Teixeria is the best player if he is available I would take him (otherwise take Howard) with one of my picks to lock up those stats.
If this was a long term keeper not just a 3 year keeper I would go Longoria. Also I assume that you can take Teixeria or Howard with one of your picks if not I would take Longoria and not take 2 MI's.
I would rank the others Rollins, Kinsler, Utley.