Fantasy Baseball Cafe Forums

by **CubsFan4Life23** » Fri Feb 06, 2009 12:22 am

So, I posted this a few weeks back and got some pretty consistent results...Most though to keep Ellsbury as my rookie, along with MCab,Kinsler... Some said keep the bats (Holliday and Markakis) then other said Johan and Holliday..Question being would Markakis be a better pick over Holliday...I think i just need a few more opinions. Thanks!!

It's a Yahoo 5x5 (runs,rbis,HRs,sb,obp)(w,sv,k,era,whip) where we keep 4 players and one '08 rookie.

My players whom I am considering keeping

Soto, Joba, Ellsbury, Max - Rookie (pick one of these)
Kinsler. Holliday, Johan, Peavy, Markakis, MCab,Papelbon (pick 4)

Thanks for all the advice...leave a link and i will respond as soon as I can.

;-D

by **Xezus** » Fri Feb 06, 2009 12:47 am

kinsler, holliday, johan, Mcab

the rookie is between Soto and ellsbury, since C are harder to get, id say Soto

by **auclairkeithbc** » Fri Feb 06, 2009 12:52 am

Xezus wrote:kinsler, holliday, johan, Mcab

the rookie is between Soto and ellsbury, since C are harder to get, id say Soto

by **ensanimal** » Fri Feb 06, 2009 12:54 am

MCab
Kinsler
Johan
Holliday

Ellsbury

by **METS 24** » Fri Feb 06, 2009 1:10 am

Deleted

by **Hustler8800** » Fri Feb 06, 2009 2:55 am

I would Keep MCab, Johan, Kinsler and Markakis. I know it sounds weird leaving Holliday out but look at his home/road splits. Coors, still, is a top hitters park. A's park on the other hand, is not. The lineup he is in is nothing short of horrible. So take either Markakis or Holliday, I like the upside. For the rookies I would take Soto.