Which 8 to keep? - WHIR

[jonboy418]

I agree with the list you have. Throwing Davis back hurts, but you are swamped at 1B and 3B and a roster spot for him would be a waste (unless you have a CI roster slot).

With those scoring categories, it definately favors power hitting, which you obviously have. With Reyes, you have a strong foundation in SB, so all in all, I think you're starting with a great roster!

Yes,the scroing also favors high K pitchers, but those are easily found in the middle to late rounds in the draft (even off the wire if you're quick). Webb as your ace pitcher... yeah that's fine.

[soty]

Thanks for all the help guys. Yes I agree with you people that say its tough to throw back Davis, but he has to with the other guys I have. I personally think my power is good enough where I can afford to. I also think that if I had an extra spot it would be Felix I would keep not Davis, so I would have another good, young SP. So with that said baring any trade(s) my 8 keepers will be:

Miguel Cabrera
Adrian Gonzalez
Evan Longoria
Nick Markakis
Carlos Quentin
Manny Ramirez
Jose Reyes
Brandon Webb

With Felix Hernandez and Chris Davis just missing the cut.

[soty]

Thanks again for all the help guys. I just wanted to let those of you who helped me know that I was able to upgrade threw trades. I landed Kinsler so now I have a good, young core of players at every position. My keepers are now:

Miguel Cabrera
Ian Kinsler
Evan Longoria
Jose Reyes
Adrian Gonzalez
Nick Markakis
Carlos Quentin
Brandon Webb

[GiantsFan14]

Thanks again for all the help guys. I just wanted to let those of you who helped me know that I was able to upgrade threw trades. I landed Kinsler so now I have a good, young core of players at every position. My keepers are now:

Miguel Cabrera
Ian Kinsler
Evan Longoria
Jose Reyes
Adrian Gonzalez
Nick Markakis
Carlos Quentin
Brandon Webb

those are some sick keepers.

[soty]

Thanks again for all the help guys. I just wanted to let those of you who helped me know that I was able to upgrade threw trades. I landed Kinsler so now I have a good, young core of players at every position. My keepers are now:

Miguel Cabrera
Ian Kinsler
Evan Longoria
Jose Reyes
Adrian Gonzalez
Nick Markakis
Carlos Quentin
Brandon Webb

those are some sick keepers.

Thanks bro.

[auclairkeithbc]

I've gotta agree with just about everyone, that you have the right keepers at this point.