Need help keeping 4 whir

[wingman3110]

Need to keep 4 of these guys. Which ones?? Sizemore and Timmy for sure, i know.

1B- Derek Lee
2B- Robby Cano
3B- Mark Reynolds
SS- Jhonny Peralta
OF- Grady Sizmore
OF- Andre Ethier
OF- Michael Bourn
Util- Rick Ankiel
Util- Rickie Weeks
Util- David Ortiz

SP- Tim Lincecum
SP- Johnny Cueto
SP- Ryan Dempster
SP- Dana Eveland
SP- Gavin Floyd
SP- Zach Greinke
SP- Greg Maddux
SP- Roy Oswalt
SP- James Shields
RP- Jonathan Paplebon
RP- Huston Street
RP- Matt Thornton

Thanks and leave a link

[dirtdogs4life]

Need to keep 4 of these guys. Which ones?? Sizemore and Timmy for sure, i know.

1B- Derek Lee
2B- Robby Cano
3B- Mark Reynolds
SS- Jhonny Peralta
OF- Grady Sizmore
OF- Andre Ethier
OF- Michael Bourn
Util- Rick Ankiel
Util- Rickie Weeks
Util- David Ortiz

SP- Tim Lincecum
SP- Johnny Cueto
SP- Ryan Dempster
SP- Dana Eveland
SP- Gavin Floyd
SP- Zach Greinke
SP- Greg Maddux
SP- Roy Oswalt
SP- James Shields
RP- Jonathan Paplebon
RP- Huston Street
RP- Matt Thornton

Thanks and leave a link

[BSbludolf]

I normally wouldn't even consider keeping a closer in 4 player keeper but that's a rough looking team. No offense. I agree with the above poster.

[wingman3110]

Yeah my team kind of fell apart. Although it was a 15 team league...

[MikeeDee]

Need to keep 4 of these guys. Which ones?? Sizemore and Timmy for sure, i know.

1B- Derek Lee
2B- Robby Cano
3B- Mark Reynolds
SS- Jhonny Peralta
OF- Grady Sizmore
OF- Andre Ethier
OF- Michael Bourn
Util- Rick Ankiel
Util- Rickie Weeks
Util- David Ortiz

SP- Tim Lincecum
SP- Johnny Cueto
SP- Ryan Dempster
SP- Dana Eveland
SP- Gavin Floyd
SP- Zach Greinke
SP- Greg Maddux
SP- Roy Oswalt
SP- James Shields
RP- Jonathan Paplebon
RP- Huston Street
RP- Matt Thornton

Thanks and leave a link

Papelbon by a hair over Shields and Oswalt.

[hambone1818]

Boy, that's tough. I tend to agree with the other two, Paps is the way to go. However, I think it's very, very close with Shields. Keeping a closer in a 4-keeper system just seems....wrong. I know Shields isn't a top-10 pitcher, but his ERA/WHIP combination doesn't get beaten by many and he'll put up good W numbers on that team is only getting better. Add in that Papelbon's peripherals have gone up each of the last three seasons (granted, they had no where to go but up after the ridiculous 2006) and I think he's a bit overvalued this year.

Any thoughts on this topic?

viewtopic.php?t=366677