My Top 100 - input welcome

[Whisp]

10-team, 5x5 Roto, Non-keeper

1 ARodriguez
2 APujols
3 HRamirez
4 DWright
5 MiCabrera
6 MTeixeira
7 JReyes
8 GSizemore
9 RBraun
10 JHamilton
11 CUtley
12 RHoward
13 IKinsler
14 MHolliday
15 JRollins
16 JSantana
17 CBeltran
18 ASoriano
19 CCSabathia
20 MRamirez
21 CaLee
22 LBerkman
23 PFielder
24 CHamels
25 TLincecum
26 BWebb
27 ArRamirez
28 MKemp
29 CQuentin
30 JPeavy
31 ELongoria
32 JMorneau
33 DOrtiz
34 JBay
35 VGuerrero
36 BPhillips
37 BJUpton
38 NMarkakis
39 BRoberts
40 DHaren
41 RHalladay
42 RLudwick
43 CCrawford
44 JBeckett
45 RMartin
46 CHart
47 CGranderson
48 JNathan
49 JPapelbon
50 FRodriguez
51 CBillingsley
52 DLee
53 XNady
54 BMcCann
55 DMatsuzaka
56 AJBurnett
57 GSoto
58 CJones
59 ARios
60 HPence
61 AdGonzalez
62 NMcLouth
63 AlRamirez
64 SDrew
65 DPedroia
66 JLackey
67 MRivera
68 MOrdonez
69 DUggla
70 JMauer
71 ISuzuki
72 JEllsbury
73 GAtkins
74 CDavis
75 KYoukilis
76 ROswalt
77 SKazmir
78 CZambrano
79 JChamberlain
80 CMarmol
81 BLidge
82 JSoria
83 RHarden
84 BSheets
85 ClLee
86 JShields
87 DPrice
88 YGallardo
89 DJeter
90 MYoung
91 RCano
92 CFiggins
93 ESantana
94 FHernandez
95 FLiriano
96 JLester
97 MScherzer
98 EVolquez
99 EBedard
100 ZGreinke
Just outside top 100: JBroxton BFuentes RNolasco BAbreu JJHardy JPeralta RFurcal ADunn JDye JBruce TTulowitzki VMartinez

So my underrated players list: XNady DMatsuzaka MScherzer AJBurnett JChamberlain EBedard DPrice CMarmol GSoto RLudwick HPence
And my overrated players list: ISuzuki KYoukilis AdGonzalez FHernandez DPedroia ARios JLester BJUpton ESantana MOrdonez JMauer JEllsbury

[smoovethug]

Hanley is top 2 IMO. Tex is high, Reyes is a bit low. Hamels > Lincecum, even I wouldn't say that. Nady doesn't deserve top 100, let alone #53 above the likes of Rios, Pence, Ichiro, Magglio, Ellsbury, etc.

[auclairkeithbc]

The biggest problem I see is that your overrate almost every SP. And Nady? Come on.

[Eagle Baseball]

imo your Cubby love has shown itself. I think you overranked all the Cubs in your list. (and I am a Cub fan)

[Whisp]

to clarify, this is where i value them, not where i'll draft them. i know nady will go 150th not 50th, so i'll hold off. i think he's a sleeper slugger hitting behind arod and tex in a sick yankees lineup.

i know i rank SP higher than most people. before finishing this list i had to purposely drop every starting pitcher about 20 spots just to compensate for that fact, and it's still being noticed.

i do love cubs.

anyway thx for the input!