Help needed with Prospects...WHIR

[BigBlue]

I have back to back draft picks coming up in our prospect draft. I'm trying to decide between the following:

Pitchers
Madison Bumgarner
Tim Alderson
Trevor Cahill

C
Buster Posey

1B
Kila Ka'aihue
Gaby Sanchez
Angel Villalona

3B
Mat Gamel
Conor Gillaspie

OF
Dexter Fowler
Aaron Cunningham

Nothing special, just a standard 5x5 league. We hare able to keep 4 prospects yearly from this draft. I came into the draft holding onto LaPorta and Smardzjia.

Can you place them in the order that you'd go for them in?

[Big Cat Court]

Bumgarner
Posey
Cahill
Alderson
Fowler
Gamel
Villalona

The rest are a bit interchangeable in my mind, and don't offer a ton of upside. The top four up there are all elite prospects, and can be reasonably expected to develop into solid + big league players. Cahill and Posey are the closest to the show, BTW, if that matters to you.

[rupertoooo]

I would also select Bumgarner and Posey. Although with Bumgarner, Posey, Cahill and Fowler I also believe it is a flip of the coin for who is the best. All four of these guys have nice resumes, but again all four could fail.

If SP is your strong suite I would probably go with Posey and Fowler due to the fact the SP is generally a crap shoot, In addition Bumgarner is at least a couple of years away. Regardless I would at least draft one of Posey or Fowler know matter which direction you go.

[MikeeDee]

Bumgarner
Posey
Cahill
Fowler
I'd rank them in that order.

Try to get two of those if you can.