Pick 1 of 3 - Best keepers

[RyeWhiskey]

12 team, H2H, 9-player keeper league. These are the top 3 teams of keepers coming into the draft. Which do you think is best?

Team A:
1B - A. Gonzalez
2B - I. Kinsler
3B - E. Longoria
OF - A. Soriano
OF - M. Holliday
SP - T. Lincecum
SP - R. Harden
SP - E. Santana
SP - R. Oswalt

Team B:
1B - A. Pujols
2B - C. Utley
3B - D. Wright
SS - J. Reyes
OF - C. Beltran
OF - V. Guerrero
SP - C. Zambrano
SP - Z. Grienke
SP - D. Price

Team C:
1B - R. Howard
2B - B. Phillips
3B - M. Cabrera
OF - G. Sizemore
OF - A. Rios
OF - C. Hart
Util - N. McLouth
SP - J. Santana
SP - J. Peavy

[adeehr]

Wow those are all good keeper teams. But I like A the best because of the future value of Kinsler, Longoria and Lincecum.

Otherwise for the best team this coming year it's hard to argue with team B. Stacked for sure.

[Chicago 2]

Those are 3 ridiculously good teams.

Stacked for sure.

Ranking them for this year:

Team B
Team A
Team C

[mocabeenow]

B

The thought of owning Pujols, Utley, Wright, and Reyes is a dream i could never imagined. IMO. You have #1 1B, #1 2B, #2 3B, #2 SS. And they don't get hurt... typically!

I think A was my second choice, but youth and some past injuries woo'd me to B.

C's pitching keepers I drool over, which made me give it some thought. But i'm not impressed with a couple middle tier OF's.

Moc

[Kimbos Beard]

I have to go

1) B - outrageous infield, enough said. The pitching is the weakest of all three but who cares with an infield like that.

2) A - the edge goes slightly to A here. I think they are younger and have much greater potential. The pitching after Lincecum is a little iffy to me, because of Harden's health and Oswalt's age.

3) C - the other teams are so stacked the weakness of the outfield hurts this team. That being said all three teams are studly, and I would be more than happy to have this team's core going into the season.

[MikeeDee]

This year:
A
B
C


2010 and beyond:
A
C
B

[BoBtheMule]

this makes me wonder how the other nine teams look b/c these three should pretty much destroy everyone else...

[RyeWhiskey]

Thanks for the replies everyone! And please leave a link if you'd like my help with anything.

What would you say if team C looked like this:

1B - M. Cabrera
2B - B. Phillips
3B - A. Rodriguez
OF - G. Sizemore
OF - N. Markakis
SP - J. Santana
SP - J. Peavy
SP - C. Billingsley

?

[sbabaganush]

Wow deff the new Team C is better than team A, B ,C. Has the best balance of great hitting and pitching. Wheras, Team B has awesom hitting but so-so pitching, Team A has a decent balance and the best pitching of the first three and the old C just does not compare to the first two.

[CadensDad]

I like the new team C best but before it would have been B.A.C.