FBC Community Top 20 OF - #4: Matt Holliday, #5: C. Beltran

[RedSoxNation04]

Holiday his SBs are pretty valuable and and he has a pretty good line up.
I like Beltran right behind him, they are basically the same player but Holiday is younger.

His SB's are only valuable if Oakland lets him run. Typically, they don't.

[GiantsFan14]

Holiday his SBs are pretty valuable and and he has a pretty good line up.
I like Beltran right behind him, they are basically the same player but Holiday is younger.

His SB's are only valuable if Oakland lets him run. Typically, they don't.

they were 14th in the mlb in steals last year, i think they'll let him run a bit.

i still went with Beltran though.

[Yoda]

Holiday his SBs are pretty valuable and and he has a pretty good line up.
I like Beltran right behind him, they are basically the same player but Holiday is younger.

His SB's are only valuable if Oakland lets him run. Typically, they don't.

they were 14th in the mlb in steals last year, i think they'll let him run a bit.

i still went with Beltran though.

But their SB% was way above average. Attempted steals still puts them near the bottom third.

I voted Holliday. I think you are still splitting hairs at this point so i went with the younger guy over Beltran.

[rb11]

His SB's are only valuable if Oakland lets him run. Typically, they don't.

they were 14th in the mlb in steals last year, i think they'll let him run a bit.

i still went with Beltran though.

But their SB% was way above average. Attempted steals still puts them near the bottom third.

I voted Holliday. I think you are still splitting hairs at this point so i went with the younger guy over Beltran.

Doesn't it make sense that their average would be higher if they were bottom 3rd in steals attempted. Seems logical to me.

[GiantsFan14]

they were 14th in the mlb in steals last year, i think they'll let him run a bit.

i still went with Beltran though.

But their SB% was way above average. Attempted steals still puts them near the bottom third.

I voted Holliday. I think you are still splitting hairs at this point so i went with the younger guy over Beltran.

Doesn't it make sense that their average would be higher if they were bottom 3rd in steals attempted. Seems logical to me.

# of steals attempted shouldnt have any bearing on success %

[Yoda]

But their SB% was way above average. Attempted steals still puts them near the bottom third.

I voted Holliday. I think you are still splitting hairs at this point so i went with the younger guy over Beltran.

Doesn't it make sense that their average would be higher if they were bottom 3rd in steals attempted. Seems logical to me.

Their success rate of 80%+ was unusually high compared to the norm which was around 70% Their SB totals were high because they had an unusually high success rate but as it normalize, the total should go down.

[bigh0rt]

If Holliday beats Beltran here, I give up.

[AquaMan2342]

If Holliday beats Beltran here, I give up.

Seconded.

[AussieDodger]

If Holliday beats Beltran here, I give up.

You give up what? W----ing over Beltran?

[CadensDad]

I may have jumped the gun, but I guess my faith in him is strong. I went Crawford