Cliff Lee/V Wells for Haren/C Young(CF)

[Gandalf]

6x6 with OPS and holds added.

Same positions, same money, both OF signed for 4 years, both SPs for 3 years

Which pair would you rather have on your roster?

[AussieDodger]

Haren/CBYoung by far.

Cliff Lee is all over the place in his career, who knows what you'll get with him.
Vernon Wells is decent.

But Haren and CBY both have the skills to be elite.

Giant gap for me.

[OneLoveBoomer]

Haren / CYoung and it's not even close. Both players are better than their counterparts in this deal, by the way I rank 'em!


Help?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=366145

[DTChiefs]

I agree with the previous 2. Easy pick-Haren/Young

[AuburnTigers]

I would go with Haren/Young. Haren is the star of the 4 players mentioned and C. Young has potential even though he struggled last year. Lee can only go down from here and Wells has about as much risk as Young does IMO. Go with Haren/Young

[GiantsFan14]

Haren/CBYoung by far.

Cliff Lee is all over the place in his career, who knows what you'll get with him.
Vernon Wells is decent.

But Haren and CBY both have the skills to be elite.

Giant gap for me.

Aussie is on fire, Haren and Young for sure.

[stlouiscards33]

The haren side of the deal wins by far in this deal. Young>Wells Haren>Cliff lee

[auclairkeithbc]

i would also go with the Haren side, but I don't think it is nearly as far apart as everyone else thinks.

can you help me out...?
viewtopic.php?t=366484

[ayebatter]

i would also go with the Haren side, but I don't think it is nearly as far apart as everyone else thinks.

Yes it is

[gtvisa]

another vote for haren/young.