bigh0rt wrote:* ThatDude, the Vigilante is trying to be the last person alive, like in previous Mafia games, correct? Or does he count as a regular townie and once all the mafia are eliminated, the town and he win together??
I thought the Serial Killer was always the guy trying to be the last man alive, not the Vigilante.
Anyway....The Vigilante is town-aligned, and wins with them.
Sometimes it takes a crazy person to see the truth. If so, I'm a freaking lunatic.
bigh0rt wrote:* ThatDude, the Vigilante is trying to be the last person alive, like in previous Mafia games, correct? Or does he count as a regular townie and once all the mafia are eliminated, the town and he win together??
I thought the Serial Killer was always the guy trying to be the last man alive, not the Vigilante.
Anyway....The Vigilante is town-aligned, and wins with them.
teddy ballgame wrote:So the mafia killed BigPimpin and the vigilante killed Northsider. Interesting that both of these people had votes on them during Day 1. I don't think the people who made these votes would then go and kill that person the same night, so I think someone was trying to set up both Snakes and h0rt. Not that means either of them are innocent.
I guess if this is the case the question is why the vigilante would want to set someone up? Either they weren't, or the vigilante believed whoever they were setting up was mafia, and this would be a good way to cast suspicion on them.
I don't remember the point I was going to make because now the only thing I can conclude from this is that maybe the vigilante thinks Snakes is mafia...I guess.
Sorry guys, college starts back up tomorrow so I've been busy the past couple of days. I don't think this really makes sense because if the vigilante thought that Snakes was mafia, why would he even bother setting him up. He could have just killed him instead of taking a chance on killing a townie instead.
teddy ballgame wrote:So the mafia killed BigPimpin and the vigilante killed Northsider. Interesting that both of these people had votes on them during Day 1. I don't think the people who made these votes would then go and kill that person the same night, so I think someone was trying to set up both Snakes and h0rt. Not that means either of them are innocent.
I guess if this is the case the question is why the vigilante would want to set someone up? Either they weren't, or the vigilante believed whoever they were setting up was mafia, and this would be a good way to cast suspicion on them.
I don't remember the point I was going to make because now the only thing I can conclude from this is that maybe the vigilante thinks Snakes is mafia...I guess.
Sorry guys, college starts back up tomorrow so I've been busy the past couple of days. I don't think this really makes sense because if the vigilante thought that Snakes was mafia, why would he even bother setting him up. He could have just killed him instead of taking a chance on killing a townie instead.
You're right. I got confused somewhere in my post about the vigilante's intentions, but they are with the town and by the end I knew something didn't add up.
Snakes Gould wrote:honestly, i had (probably still dont) no idea what was going on, and still dont know if bp can come back or not. he's "missing" but is he alive?
From the original role description....
Can make a person disappear. If the person he chooses dies that same night, the Janitor will clean up the mess and dispose of it. He will learn the exact role of the victim in the process, and that role will NOT be revealed in the game thread. There will simply be "______ has disappeared." Can only perform this action once in a game, so after he's done it, he essentially becomes a plain ol mafia.
Sometimes it takes a crazy person to see the truth. If so, I'm a freaking lunatic.
Snakes Gould wrote:honestly, i had (probably still dont) no idea what was going on, and still dont know if bp can come back or not. he's "missing" but is he alive?
From the original role description....
Can make a person disappear. If the person he chooses dies that same night, the Janitor will clean up the mess and dispose of it. He will learn the exact role of the victim in the process, and that role will NOT be revealed in the game thread. There will simply be "______ has disappeared." Can only perform this action once in a game, so after he's done it, he essentially becomes a plain ol mafia.
i get what's going on in the actual game but i have no idea how to analyze it or process it in terms of why/who. it took quite a few games of mafia to hone my skills and with these roles, im sure it requires the same amount of time.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by ThatDude » Tue Jan 13, 2009 6:40 pm 
