NL only Tulo/Drew/Loney

[prusaw]

8 team Nl only, 5x5 roto, 7 keeper...

Would you keep: Kershaw ($11- 3 yrs), Drew ($9- 2yrs), Tulo ($6 1 yr), Loney ($1-1 yr)

How would you rank the 4 players?

I'm leaning toward Kershaw (though I already have Santana and Gallardo as keepers)

[bigh0rt]

Who are your other keepers and specs on them?

I like them ranked as they're listed, but I'd really like to try and get you to keep Kershaw and Drew both, if possible.

[San D]

I would keep Drew for $9 for the 2 years. He and Tulo are very close in my opinion, but the extra year weighs more to me than the $3.

Loney for $1 is nice, but the savings over the SS prices doesn't weigh as much to me as their differences in ADP. Kershaw doesn't measure up to me at $11 even though it is 3 years.

[Whalewang]

Drew, Kershaw, tulo, Loney.

The rest of your list matters though. Drew is clearly the best keeper with Loney far behind.
Kershaw and tulo are close.

[stevethumb]

wow tough call...i have them rated one dollar apart from tulo (highest) to kershaw (lowest) but your salaries and contracts really make it interesting...i guess i would have to know your entire roster and more info regarding your league to make an informed decision

[GiantsFan14]

drew
kershaw
tulo
loney

the extra year on kershaw is tempting, but i think that drew has proven it in the big leagues while kershaw has not overrides that.

[The Artful Dodger]

I'd go with Drew for two years. I think Kershaw will continue to be a work in progress, even if it doesn't surprise me if he breaks out by the third year a la Billingsley.

[prusaw]

My other keepers would be:

Wright- 42
Santana- 39
Aramis Ramirez- 26
R. Martin 8
Gallardo - 1
Fielder- 26

I really want Kershaw, but I could keep Drew for cheap and then likely pick up Kershaw in the draft with my #2 pick (for the same price).... though I might have a shot at some other good players instead (Harang, Votto??, Vasquez, ...)

[Field]

drew
kershaw
tulo
loney

the extra year on kershaw is tempting, but i think that drew has proven it in the big leagues while kershaw has not overrides that.

This is how I would rank them also. Kershaw and Drew are close, but I give the slight edge to Drew.

[bigh0rt]

My other keepers would be:

Wright- 42
Santana- 39
Aramis Ramirez- 26
R. Martin 8
Gallardo - 1
Fielder- 26

I really want Kershaw, but I could keep Drew for cheap and then likely pick up Kershaw in the draft with my #2 pick (for the same price).... though I might have a shot at some other good players instead (Harang, Votto??, Vasquez, ...)

Yeah, there's no swapping out any of those guys. Keep Drew. Draft Kershaw or Votto if they are available.