Marmol or Scherzer for My last Keeper?

[wackadoodle]

I'm in a ten team NL only league. Six keepers each year. My first five keepers are set but my last one is down to either Max Scherzer or Carlos Marmol. Thoughts?

[moochie]

Does your league use holds or saves or both?

[eclecticj]

It's been a few years since i've played NL only, but as I remember closers go fast. I can only imagine this is even more true in a keeper league. I'd go with marmol.

[moochie]

Off hand I'd go with Marmol

[wackadoodle]

Saves. Standard 5x5

[AussieDodger]

Scherzer only threw 109 total innings last year between AAA/bigs, so in 2009 you'll probably get 139 max.
Worth your while waiting for him to go 139/169/199? Maybe next year.

[ayebatter]

Scherzer only threw 109 total innings last year between AAA/bigs, so in 2009 you'll probably get 139 max.
Worth your while waiting for him to go 139/169/199? Maybe next year.

Scherzer The only closer I'd keep over him would be FRod, UNLESS........10 other closers are typically kept yr to yr.

[GiantsFan14]

marmol for me

[Neato Torpedo]

Scherzer only threw 109 total innings last year between AAA/bigs, so in 2009 you'll probably get 139 max.
Worth your while waiting for him to go 139/169/199? Maybe next year.

In a likely DBacks playoff contention year? I doubt they'd be quite as conservative with him.

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd go with Marmol