Full dynasty H2H league, 15 minors spots. Trade is as follows:
I Give Up: Granderson, Cain, Garza, Capps
I Get: Peavy, Marmol, Milledge, Jensen Lewis (just a throw in, I suppose).
The other important pieces on my team, in terms of helping make a decision on this trade:
My outfield has Markakis and Guerrero, as well as Adam Jones and Travis Snider as youngsters. My rotation has Hamels, Lackey, Liriano, Beckett, Verlander.
I am not sure what I think about this offer. I love getting Peavy, who is a young (27) stud, and adding him to my rotation would make it lights out. Cain / Garza are both full of upside and are even younger, however, so it pains me to give them both up. Marmol is an upgrade over Capps. Granderson is real good, but may have peaked in 2007. Between Milledge, Snider, Jones there is a decent chance one of them rises up and plays as well as Granderson anyway.
Any help would be appreciated.