Dynasty trade: my JJohnson for MYoung

[Field]

I would hold onto Johnson actually. Young doesn't really excite me, even though its not a bad deal.

[archie23]

I like Josh Johnson I feel he is a ace in the making and Young has seen his better days. I still like Young, but I like Johnson better. If it's a keeper league I would definetly do the trade.

[B-Chad]

With this being a dynasty league I'm less then thrilled with the idea of dealing Josh Johnson for Michael Young. I certainly think Young will produce this year, but give his age and production decline I'd be more inclined to keep the high upside uber young Josh Johnson. He's already shown in spurts what he's capable of, and he's still in a way, honing his craft. Anyway, you could swing a smaller scale deal to get a stand in/upside type SS like Brandon Wood. Maybe deal a lesser arm for an older lesser bat like Edgar Renteria, or a younger less proven bat like Aviles? If I'm dealing Josh Johnson I'd want someone younger like Jhonny Peralta, J.J. Hardy, or Stephen Drew back. Any chance you could help me with mine I'd greatly appreciate it. Thanks.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=365018