Mauer for Holliday?

[davercomeau]

Would you trade Joe Mauer for Matt Holliday in a keeper league?

[jeffmerk]

Holliday is less of an injury risk.

[oakscorps]

It would depend on your roster, but I would rather have Holliday in most cases

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd rather have Holiday.

[MaudDib]

I would take Holliday pretty easily over Mauer. I know C is kind of slim but Holliday is one of the top OF even with his move to Oakland.

[GiantsFan14]

yes and it's not close. first of all i think the move to oakland is being a bit overblown, i don't think it will have as huge as an effect as people seem to believe. also, it's a keeper league, and in a year (if not sooner) holliday will most likely be out of oakland and on a big market team again.

[ayebatter]

Holliday

[The Artful Dodger]

Holliday, easily. No matter how much Holliday is going to regress (I frankly think he really won't fall off that much), he carries much greater upside across the board than Mauer does.

[Dan Charette]

Holliday ,any day .

[B-Chad]

Holliday in a landslide. His numbers will be far and away better than Mauer's. I personally believe Joe Mauer ranks amongst the most overrated fantasy players. I also think the position scarcity at catcher is not what it once was. Guys like McCann, Martin, V-Mart, Soto, Doumit, Iannetta, Sandoval add to what is becoming an increasingly less scarce position. Little help with mine if you don't mind. viewtopic.php?t=364919