MY CARLOS LEE FOR BWEBB?! WHIR!!!!

[bigh0rt]

I don't think that Soriano trade will be approved. It will take Alfonso and an arm to get Webb in almost all leagues.

That's just not true.

[ayebatter]

I'd rather have Lee or Soriano over Webb. Generally, I'd rather have a stud hitter over stud pitcher, especially in this case when Webb isn't a K-intensive pitcher.

As far as who I'd keep:

Jay Bruce
Josh Hamilton
Carlos Lee
Brian Roberts
Alfonso Soriano
Shane Victorino
David Wright
Jose Reyes

Felix Hernandez
Yovani Gallardo

I'm not particularly high on Dice-K and so I left him off. I'd try packaging him with any of your other likely keepers for an upgraded keeper.

In agreement here, I also don't think I'd make a deal for Hamels either, although one couldn't fault you for moving one of Lee/Soriano for Hamels.

[jackthree]

Hi guys,

Tonight I traded Carlos Lee, Felix, and a pick (2nd rounder) for Cole Hamels, Justin Morneau and a 4th round pick.

I am VERY pleased to come away with a first baseman to fill the hole I had since I gave up Pena (Pena/Figgins/Johan for Reyes) and I was able to add a top of the line starter to replace Johan.

Even though I love Felix, I think coming away this offseason with the following three deals makes my team significantly better.

I traded:
1. Tulo and a 6th for Yovani and a 1st (which I didnt have one of)
2. Johan, Carlos Pena and Figgins for Jose Reyes (I couldn't have kept one of Pena or Figgins probably)
3. Carlos Lee, Felix Hernandez and a 2nd round pick for Cole Hamels and Justin Morneau and a 4th round pick.

Thanks for the help!