Which list of 8 keepers is better for 12 team H2H

[oakscorps]

Team A

Mccann
Pujols
Kinsler
Reyes
WRight
Quentin
Sizemore
Rios at RF or keep Pedoria at UTIL either one (even to me)

Team B

Pujols
Kinsler
Reyes
Wright
Quentin
Sizemore
Rios
Peavy

Team C

Mccann
Pujols
Kinsler
Reyes
Wright
Quentin
Sizemore
Webb

[GiantsFan14]

i like C

[fast dogs]

I C it that way too

[NY Knights]

Yep, I think it's C. Initially I thought about Pedroia, but with Reyes, Sizemore and Kinsler already in your lineup, you have speed covered, so go with the banger in McCann

[oakscorps]

Awesome its what I wanted to hear

I'm currently involved in a 3 team deal where I would be giving up Peavy, Votto and Liriano and getting Pedoria and Mccann

THen trading Pedoria, Rios, and Cliff Lee for Webb

Which would allow me to have C keepers instead of my original keepers which is B

[ayebatter]

In a h2h I'd rather have this team

Team B

Pujols
Kinsler
Reyes
Wright
Quentin
Sizemore
Rios
Peavy

[Grounded Polo]

B, Rios is more valuable than McCann and Peavy/Webb is a wash but Peavy is younger.

[The Artful Dodger]

I like B. You have a very well rounded offense with C being the only possible deficiency, which isn't a loss I'd mind at all. I'd still rather have Peavy over Webb for the better K rate.