Rank These Quality SPs

[Seanyfever]

Rank the followign please.... Will reply to links.

Try 2009 and 2010...for
Johan... CC... Peavy... Beckett... Lincecum

[rookies and cream]

1) Johan
2) Lincecum
3) Peavy
4) CC
5) Beckett

[ayebatter]

Peavy
Johan
CC
Lincecum
Beckett

[HOOTIE]

1) Johan
2) Lincecum
3) Peavy
4) CC
5) Beckett

[GiantsFan14]

on pure 2009 projection, i have lincecum above santana, but i'd probably still rank santana first for less risk/consistency.

santana
lincecum
CC
peavy
beckett

[San D]

Santana
Lincecum
Sabathia
Peavy
Beckett

[RunReyesRun]

Johan
CC
Lincecum
Peavy
Beckett

[Dan Charette]

1) Johan
2) Lincecum
3) Peavy
4) CC
5) Beckett

i agree with this order.

[abrage22]

1) Johan
2) Lincecum
3) Peavy
4) CC
5) Beckett

[MrE]

Rank the followign please.... Will reply to links.

Try 2009 and 2010...for
Johan... CC... Peavy... Beckett... Lincecum

2009:
1) Johan 2) Lincecum 3) CC 4) Peavy 5) Beckett

2010:
1) Johan 2) CC 3) Lincecum 4) Peavy 5) Beckett

I think Tim's arm is going to show signs of wear/tear in 2010, but it might happen this year. He is a phenomenal pitcher, but he is still young and he was abused innings and pitch count wise last year. Peavy, I also fear for on his arm, but I ranked him behind CC only because I think CC has a legitimate chance to win 20+ a year in New York, whereas it will be a struggle for Peavy to win 15.

Please return the favor:

viewtopic.php?t=364701