i have moustakas/p alvarez/gamel/nef feliz

[coop777]

i can keep 3 of the 4..who would u throw back and why...

[oddmanout7]

Bye bye Gamel. The others 3 guys are in my top 20 prospects. Gamel struggled significantly after the AS break, hitting below the Mendoza line.

[King Tim]

Bye bye Gamel. The others 3 guys are in my top 20 prospects. Gamel struggled significantly after the AS break, hitting below the Mendoza line.

[coop777]

gamel battled elbow problems thus the drop in production.......and he's closest to the majors...does this change ur opinion?

[cardinal1975]

I also agree Gamel is your drop. The other 3 have much higher ceilings.

[bigken117]

the decision for me is between Moustakas and Gamel...and I think it would be Gamel I throw back. Definitely a tough decision.

[oddmanout7]

gamel battled elbow problems thus the drop in production.......and he's closest to the majors...does this change ur opinion?

"After being arguably the best hitter in the minors during the first half of the season, with a .375/.433/.612 line on July 12, third baseman Mat Gamel went into a horrible slump, batting just .189/.283/.315 the rest of the way with no real explanation or obvious cause. He also remains a third baseman in name only after committing 32 errors there, giving him a whopping 119 miscues over the last three years." - SI

From what I have read, he didn't disclose an injury, and while that would soften my stance against him if he were indeed battling and injury during his slump, I would still take the others over him. I see Gamel having a productive career, but the other 3 guys have the chance to be perennial all stars. Also, as a 1B, Gamel isn't nearly as intriguing.

[BigLebowski]

Gamel would be the one to go if I had to choose.