Depends on the scoring system and how much closers go for in your league. I'd probably go Soria. If you only get to keep them one more year I don't know that Davis will have even hit his stride yet by the time you have to drop him - Soria has... And remember 10 of those HR came in like 90 AB...
I have to stay under $180**Can only keep one FA** Doumit-FA-$10 Snyder-$1 Huff-$1 Kinsler-$12 M.Cabrera-$48 Furcal-$6 mi-Polanco-$1 ci-Figgins-$17 Holliday-$53, Hamilton-$20,Damon-$3,J.Upton-FA-$10, u-C.Davis-FA-$10 p-CZam-$15,Lilly-$6,Gallardo-$3,Arroyo-$1,Unit-$2,BJ Ryan-$1,Soria-FA-$10,Pelfrey-FA-$10,Scherzer-FA-$10. .....Thanks for your advice!!
Who can I offer in trade for Howard?..or maybe Fielder and Alexei?...My team: Doumit-FA-$10 Snyder-$1 Huff-$1 Kinsler-$12 M.Cabrera-$48 Furcal-$6 mi-Polanco-$1 ci-Figgins-$17 Holliday-$53, Hamilton-$20,Damon-$3,J.Upton-FA-$10, u-C.Davis-FA-$10 p-CZam-$15,Lilly-$6,Gallardo-$3,Arroyo-$1,Unit-$2,BJ Ryan-$1,Soria-FA-$10,Pelfrey-FA-$10,Scherzer-FA-$10. Him: c-AJ-$2, Buck-$2 1b Fielder-$55(he might drop or trade) 2b-Alexei Ramirez-$10(his one FA to keep) ss Jeter-$31(he might drop) mi-Tejada-$16(he might drop) ci Howard-$52 of Griffey-$7, McLouth-$10, Byrd-$10, Guillen-$10, Kotsay-$3 and Utility D.ortiz-$30 P-CC-$21, Sheets-$6, Garza-$10,Jerad Weaver-$9, J.Johnson-$10, Byrd-$10, Broxton-$1, campillo-$10